Sharp dog, ruined shot: backgrounds in dogs in action photography
You nailed it. The dog is coming straight at you, both front legs off the ground, ears up, eyes locked on the ball. You check the back of the camera and the eye is tack sharp.
And the photo still looks wrong.
You blame the light. You blame the lens. You start wondering whether the 300mm would have saved it. It would not have, and here is why.
Nine times out of ten the frame is not failing because of the dog. It is failing because of the two meters of world sitting right behind him, and in dogs in action photography that is the part almost nobody looks at.
The background rule in dogs in action photography
A background does not have to be ugly to ruin a photo. It only has to compete.
Four things make it compete, and they are worth naming, because once you can name them you start seeing them before you press the shutter instead of after.
It is too close. The nearer the background sits to the dog, the sharper your lens renders it. A hedge three meters behind him stays readable, and anything readable asks for attention. The dog has to fight for the eye.
It is brighter than the dog. The eye goes to the brightest thing in the frame, always, and it does not ask your permission. A patch of white sky behind a dark dog wins every time, no matter how good the action is.
It has lines in it. A fence post, a lamp post, a bare branch. They grow out of the dog's head and back, and once you see it you cannot unsee it. Horizontal lines are worse than vertical ones, because they cut the animal in half.
It matches his coat. A sable dog against autumn bracken. A white dog against a pale gravel path. The colors are beautiful and the dog disappears into them, because separation is what makes a subject read as a subject.
Five moves, in order of power
These are in order. The first one costs nothing and fixes more than the last one, which costs two thousand euro.
1. Move yourself. Not the dog. Two steps to your left and the lamp post is gone. Three steps right and the pale path behind him becomes dark grass. This is the most underused fix in dog photography, and photographers skip it because moving the dog feels like the active choice and moving yourself feels like giving up. It is the opposite.
2. Put distance behind him. Do not look for a pretty background, look for a far one. A mediocre treeline eighty meters away beats a beautiful hedge five meters away, every time, because distance is what melts detail. Choose where the dog runs so that what is behind him is as far away as you can arrange.
3. Drop your height. Getting low does two things at once. It makes the dog look powerful, and it swaps the near ground behind him for something much further away, often the sky or a distant horizon. One movement, two problems solved.
4. Open up and go long. Now the gear matters, but only now. A longer focal length compresses and narrows what fits behind the dog, and a wider aperture softens what is left. This is the fourth move and not the first, because a 300mm pointed at a close cluttered hedge still gives you a close cluttered hedge.
5. Choose the direction of the run. Before you throw the ball, look at what the dog will be running against. Most photographers choose the spot. Choose the line instead.
The autumn trap
Autumn is the best season you get, and it hides the meanest background problem of the year.
The color is spectacular, the light is low and long, wet trunks go almost black. And the trees are losing leaves, which means the canopy that used to be a solid dark wall is now full of bright holes of sky.
Those holes are exactly the pattern the eye cannot ignore: small, bright, scattered, right behind your subject. You come home with a photo of a beautiful dog covered in white confetti (that could be amazing if not clipped and well blurred by the lens at maximum aperture).
Fix it by dropping your height until the holes go above the frame, or by moving until the dog is against a soft brown instead of canopy.
Not sure whether your lens is helping or hurting here? The free lesson on choosing a lens for dogs in action work covers exactly what focal length and aperture do to a background, and what they cannot do. Watch the free lesson
What to do on your next session
One thing only. Before you throw anything, stand where you plan to shoot from and look at the frame without the dog in it.
If the background is boring, you are in the right place. Boring is the goal. In dogs in action photography, a background's only job is to not take the photo away from your subject.
Everything else, how to read the dog's line a second before he commits, how to work the light you have instead of the light you wanted, how to finish the frame in Lightroom so the separation you built on location survives the edit, is in the full course.
Comments