top of page
Search

Your screen shows less than 2% of the photo: sharpness in dogs in action photography

Nov 13
3 min read

You check the back of the camera after the run. The dog is in the air, the ears are up, the eye looks sharp. You move on.

At home you open the file at 100% and the eye is soft. Not ruined. Just soft. Too soft for a print, too soft for a client.

The screen didn't lie to you. It never had enough pixels to tell you the truth.

Black and white border collie leaping over a rock toward the camera in the woods, front paws tucked, eyes on the lens


Sharpness in dogs in action photography


Look at the top full-frame cameras of the big brands, the ones built for action. The rear screen is almost always the same: 2.1 million dots, which means about 700,000 pixels. The file it is showing you has 45 million on the high-resolution models, 24 million on the fastest ones.

When you look at the whole frame, every pixel on the screen stands in for about 65 pixels of your photo. The screen shows you about 1.5% of what you recorded and fills the gap by averaging.

A sharp eye and a slightly soft eye, averaged 65 to 1, look exactly the same.


How much of your photo you actually see


The whole photo, on each of the places where you usually look at it. Two files: 45 and 24 megapixels, the two sizes these cameras shoot. For the viewfinder I used the average, because here these cameras differ a lot: from 3.7 to 9.4 million dots.

Where you look at the whole photo

45 MP file

24 MP file

Camera screen

1.5%

2.9%

Viewfinder (average)

4.5%

8.5%

Instagram, horizontal photo (1080 px wide)

1.7%

3.2%

Full HD monitor

3.9%

7.3%

4K monitor

15%

29%

5K monitor

27%

52%

Print 20x30 cm (8x12 in) at 300 dpi

18%

35%

Print 30x45 cm (12x18 in)

41%

78%

Print 40x60 cm (16x24 in)

74%

more than the file holds


Two things jump out.

The place where you decide whether the shot is good, the camera screen, is the one that shows you the least. Even the viewfinder doesn't reach 5% of a 45 MP file.

And the place where softness finally shows up is the place where it's too late to fix it: the big monitor at home, or the print on the wall. Instagram sits right next to the camera screen. A photo can look perfectly sharp on a phone and still fail at 30x45 cm.


What the screen can tell you, and what it can't


On the camera screen, whole frame

Can you judge it?

Framing: ears, paws or tail cut off

Yes

Expression, ears, tongue

Yes

A burned sky or a frame too dark, with the histogram

Yes

Eye sharp or slightly soft

No

Focus on the nose instead of the eye

Not reliably

Light motion blur on the fur

No

Fine detail in a black coat

No


The screen is a great tool for the first three lines. For the other four it is close to useless, and those four are the ones that decide whether a photo can be printed.


What a "slightly soft" eye looks like


Comparison of a border collie running through dandelion seeds: top row, the whole frame at screen size, sharp and slightly blurred, looking the same; bottom row, the eyes at 100 percent, where the blur is obvious

Top row: the whole photo at screen size. On the left the original, on the right the same file with a light blur added. They look like the same photo.

Bottom row: the eye at 100%. Now the difference is obvious. The bottom row is what a print shows, and what a client sees when the photo arrives.


The lost photo


In dogs in action photography, this is how a good photo gets lost. The dog came straight at you, the screen said sharp, you went on to the next run. The one frame that mattered was soft, and you found out at home.

Dogs don't repeat a jump with the same light, the same expression and the same ears.

Zooming in on every frame in the field isn't the answer. While you scroll and pinch, the next run starts without you. And shooting more frames "to be safe" doesn't help either: twenty soft frames are still twenty soft frames.


What changes when you know this


Use the screen for what it can do: framing, expression, exposure. Sharpness is a different job. It's decided before you press, by how the camera is set up and by what the autofocus is following.

When that part is right, a sharp eye is not something you hope to find at home. It's what you expect. That's the part I teach.

If the problem you see at home is a sharp nose and soft eyes, I wrote about that in Sharp nose, soft eyes.


Black and white border collie catching a red disc in mid-air against a dark green background

Enjoyed this? The free course starts here


Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page